Lisa Rinna reportedly brought full Housewife energy to The Traitors reunion. And insiders claim Colton Underwood was not ready for it.
Sources say the Real Housewives of Beverly Hills alum confronted Colton about his “hostage” comment from earlier this season. The tense exchange allegedly ended with him walking off the set.
If true, it was the showdown fans have been waiting for.
The Traitors: “Let’s Talk About You Being a Stalker”
The drama between Lisa and Colton did not start at the reunion.
During the season, Colton, playing as a Faithful, said in a confessional that he wanted to hold Lisa “hostage.” He suspected she was a Traitor. He later tried to strike a deal with her. He promised not to banish her if she agreed to protect him from being “murdered” in the turret.
Lisa denied being a Traitor and refused.
Colton then rallied the group to vote her out.
After the episode aired, Lisa fired back on Threads. “Let’s talk about you being a stalker,” she wrote, referencing past allegations from his ex Cassie Randolph following his season of The Bachelor.
The comment triggered backlash. Lisa later walked it back and urged fans not to send hate.
“I am totally great with Colton,” she said in a video. “Everything is great. Don’t send death threats or do anything to jeopardize somebody’s family.”
Still, the tension clearly lingered.
@lisarinnaofficial Rinna with a cold🤧 a little chatty chat re @The Traitors ♬ original sound – Lisa Rinna
The Traitors: Reunion Blowup Behind the Scenes
A source told Page Six that Lisa confronted Colton at the Season 4 reunion taping.
She allegedly pressed him hard for using the word “hostage” when describing her. An insider said Colton looked unprepared for the intensity. He eventually stormed off the set.
Another source offered a softer version. They said he simply walked away during a scheduled break because he was upset.
Either way, insiders described Lisa as fully stepping back into Housewife mode.
Colton reportedly got exactly what he asked for earlier in the season when he said he wanted the “real” Lisa.
After the taping, Lisa teased the drama on TikTok.
“We shot the reunion yesterday,” she said. “Everything was taken care of. Whether you’ll see it or not, I don’t know.”
Then she added with a smirk, “If you want a Housewife, I’ll give you a Housewife, honey. Eight years.”
That sounds like someone who knows she delivered.
Following the filming of The Traitors reunion where things allegedly got heated, Colton has unfollowed Lisa on Instagram and Rob Rausch has unfollowed Candiace 👀👀👀#TheTraitors #TheTraitorsUS pic.twitter.com/kVYrTxb3p2
— Ryan John (@RyanJohn___) February 14, 2026
The Traitors: “He Made the Show Boring”
Lisa did not stop there.
She also targeted fellow Traitor Rob Rausch. He betrayed her and Candiace Dillard Bassett during the game. Rob voted off multiple Housewives in a row, shifting the power dynamic inside the castle.
When a fan pointed out that Rob sent three Housewives home back to back, Lisa replied bluntly.
“And he made the show boring. Oh well.”
It is a bold claim, especially since Rob’s strategy arguably kept him in the game longer. But from Lisa’s perspective, removing strong personalities may have drained the drama.
And Lisa has always believed reality TV thrives on big personalities.
Candiace ending Rob R, Lisa ending Colton.
— Kat | Tara and Johnny are Icons (@Kat5022_) February 14, 2026
Oh I need Porsha to end Micheal #TheTraitors pic.twitter.com/PKq7VvtERC
The Traitors: A Housewife Never Really Retires
Lisa Rinna’s run on The Traitors proved one thing. She might have left RHOBH, but the reunion instincts never left her.
She knows how to hold someone’s feet to the fire. She knows how to create a moment. And she knows how to tease it just enough to keep viewers guessing.
Whether Colton truly stormed off or simply needed a breather, one thing is clear. The reunion was not quiet.
If Lisa hints that “what needed to be done” is complete, fans should get ready for fireworks when it airs.
Entertainment reporter covering reality TV, celebrity news, and pop culture exclusives.
