Catie promised to stay faithful once she married Josh on 90 Day Fiancé. That promise did not last. The first part of Season 12’s tell-all, which aired Sunday on TLC, revealed that Catie cheated on Josh with multiple people in the months after their wedding, and the full scope of it came out in front of the entire cast.
What Catie Admitted To
Host Shaun Robinson asked Catie about the couple’s New Year’s Eve party, and Catie answered with a laugh instead of an apology. “On New Year’s Eve, I was bad,” she said, smiling as she admitted to making out with four other people that night. Her castmates sat in silence, visibly unimpressed. Josh said he felt disappointed that she kept crossing boundaries, and when Edward suggested Josh was too nice about it, Catie shot back that her husband is “not that nice.” Producers then played footage from earlier in the season showing Catie aggressively trying to kiss her friends in front of Josh. When he confronted her about how casually she treated it, she called her reaction “stress laughing.”
Danica Exposes the Full Story
The details got worse once producers brought in Catie’s friends Ryan and Danica to talk about the marriage. According to the tell-all recap, Danica said the New Year’s Eve party happened on a rooftop, where Catie invited a “crush” from her running club and kissed him twice, once while Josh was standing right there. Danica said Catie then drank a bottle of champagne and went on to kiss two more people that night, including a man in his 50s named Robert. Josh said he had to step in when he saw Catie head into the bathroom with the first guy, and asked the man to leave. Catie admitted she is not sure how far things would have gone if Josh had not stopped it.
Catie’s Breakdown at the Tell-All
Confronted with all of it on camera, Catie fell apart. “Everyone thinks I’m a bad person. I don’t like this,” she sobbed, insisting she has been trying to get better. Moments later, her tone shifted entirely. She told Josh she could do whatever she wanted and did not have to answer to him, adding that she just wants to live her life while she is young. When castmates asked if she even wants to stay married, she broke into tears, shouted that she did not know, and walked off set. Backstage, a producer stepped in to comfort her while she continued crying, and she told Josh through tears that she thinks she does better on her own.
The OCD Explanation and the Drunk Speculation
Catie has said in the past that she struggles with OCD and has linked her impulse to kiss other people while drunk to that condition. That’s her explanation for her behavior. It’s not confirmed by a doctor on camera. So, we should treat it seriously, not as an excuse or a joke. Fans had speculated for weeks that Catie might arrive drunk to the taping. This guess came from trailers showing her drinking tequila with the cast beforehand. The tell-all footage backed that theory up, showing her drinking heavily before the cameras rolled.
A Marriage That Looks Hard to Save
What stands out watching this back is how little Catie seems interested in repairing things, at least in the moment. She swings between crying over others thinking she’s a bad person and boldly stating she’ll do what she wants. This mixed message is confusing for her husband, who sits just a few feet away. Josh, for his part, comes across as someone who already knows the answer to whether this marriage survives, even if he is not ready to say it out loud yet.
Patricia covers the Kardashians, Real Housewives, The Traitors, and Below Deck. She specializes in breaking news and celebrity updates, from business ventures to on-screen drama. Patricia has covered reality TV and entertainment for three years.
But if you divorce within two years after receiving your green card you will be deported- at least that was the rule when I got mine!