On 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way, Chloe’s bond with Johny faced a crisis. Her close friends made harsh claims. They said his cheating “probably happened every week” and never really stopped.”
The moment unfolded in Aruba.
And it changed everything.
Friends Drop the Bombshell in Aruba
At a tense dinner, Chloe finally admitted what viewers had seen develop all season. Doubt never really left.
“There’s definitely been a few other times where I’ve questioned where Jonathan was, what he was doing,” Chloe confessed. “But a lot of the times I couldn’t prove it.”
Chloe tried to hold onto hope. She insisted things felt different after moving.
“I feel like since I’ve been here that Jonathan is being faithful,” she said.
Her friends were not buying it. Not for a second.
“That’s you making an excuse for him again,” one friend shot back.
‘Is He Just Lying Better?’
The conversation turned uncomfortable fast.
“So he has been cheating lately?” a friend asked.
“No,” Chloe answered.
“What’s changed?”
Silence.
“Is he just lying better?” the friend pressed.
That question hung heavy.
And Chloe had no answer.
Send Chloe back home Johnny. She sucks. #90DayFiance #90dayfiancetheotherway pic.twitter.com/Wr0rtpJVx4
— Realitytrash (@realtimetvbinge) October 28, 2025
‘Everyone on the Island Knows His Reputation’
What followed was the most damaging claim yet.
“Everybody on the island knows that Johnny has a reputation with girls,” one friend said. “He’s proud of it. It feeds his ego.”
Then came the line that stopped the scene cold.
“In the year that they’ve been together, I think Johnny has cheated on her probably every week.”
It was the strongest allegation made on-screen so far.
And it reframed everything viewers thought they knew.
Cheating Rumors Were There All Along
This did not come out of nowhere.
Earlier episodes showed Chloe questioning Johny’s late nights.
Unexplained absences.
And the earrings in his bathroom that were not hers.
Chloe even told her mother that Johny spent nights with another woman instead of her. The fallout was emotional. And raw.
Johny admitted to seeing someone else in the past.
But he insisted it happened before things were serious.
Her friends disagreed. Loudly.
Marriage Talk Only Made Things Worse
The trust issues spilled into bigger plans.
When Chloe proposed, Johny looked stunned.
He said he was old enough to marry.
But questioned whether Chloe was ready.
That hesitation raised eyebrows.
Especially with cheating allegations swirling.
Trust vs Reality
Chloe maintained she did not believe Johny was cheating now.
Her friends insisted the pattern never stopped.
No proof appeared on screen.
No denial came directly from Johny during the scene.
What remained was a widening gap.
Between what Chloe wanted to believe.
And what everyone around her kept warning her about.
