Catie and Josh said “I do” on 90 Day Fiancé. But a growing number of fans think the marriage might be less about love than it looks. Catie declared at the tell-all that she didn’t want to be married. She then walked that statement back in part 2. Now viewers have started floating a new theory. It flips the usual narrative. Maybe Josh, not Catie, is the one with something to gain from staying married.
The couple met when Catie was pet-sitting in Josh’s hometown of Cambridge, England. Their drunken first meeting grew into a long-distance relationship. Josh eventually relocated to Portland to be with her. Catie’s history of making out with others while drunk continued even after the wedding. She has attributed the habit to her OCD. At the tell-all, she admitted she made out with multiple people on New Year’s Eve. She told Josh she didn’t have to listen to him. She burst into tears when asked if she even wanted to stay married. She said she thought she’d do better on her own. In part 2, she reversed course. “I don’t actually not want to be married,” she told the group. She explained that people who don’t know her assume she’s “nutso” for saying things she doesn’t mean when overwhelmed.
That walkback hasn’t convinced everyone. One fan commented on the couple’s Instagram, “Before you can blink an eye, she’ll be with another guy.” Others have gone further. They suggest the dynamic isn’t really about Catie’s reluctance to commit. “I honestly feel like he’s low key forcing her to be with him,” one commenter wrote. They pointed to how often Catie has said she isn’t ready or happy, only for Josh to stay anyway. A theory is now gaining traction. Some fans think Josh’s own immigration status may be a factor in why he keeps choosing to stay.
A Theory That Flips the Whole Narrative
Most of this season has framed Catie as the unstable one. Josh has looked like the patient, wronged husband. This fan theory challenges that completely. It suggests the power dynamic might run the opposite direction. There’s no confirmation behind the green card theory. It’s pure viewer speculation. But the fact that it’s gaining traction says something. Josh’s patience has started to look unconvincing to the audience. Someone who says they don’t want to be married as many times as Catie has, and whose partner still won’t leave, tends to make viewers look for a reason beyond love.
Patricia covers the Kardashians, Real Housewives, The Traitors, and Below Deck. She specializes in breaking news and celebrity updates, from business ventures to on-screen drama. Patricia has covered reality TV and entertainment for three years.
